It's Only a Play takes place entirely in the bedroom of producer Julia Budder (Katie Finneran) who is throwing a party after the opening night performance of "The Golden Egg". The first character we meet is a star-struck coat-check attendant named Gus who appropriately enough is played by a newcomer to Broadway (Micah Stock). The play-within-the-play was written by Peter Austin (Matthew Broderick), who wanted his friend James Wicker (Martin Short) to have the lead role, and directed by Frank Finger (Maulik Pancholy) who unlike the others, is hoping for his first bad review. "The Golden Egg"'s female lead is Virginia Noyes (Stockard Channing) who has seen better days, and theater critic Ira Drew (F. Murray Abraham) is mostly present to be a target of general critic-hatred. For instance, he embodies the cliche of every critic being a failed playwright.
Like its fellow Broadway satire The Producers, the headlining stars of It's Only a Play when it opened last year were Matthew Broderick and Nathan Lane, though Lane has been replaced by Martin Short. I didn't see Lane's performance, but I can imagine that Short was able to relate better to the character of a Broadway star turned sitcom actor since he has decades of television experience, and in fact the sitcom Mulaney that Short costarred in had been cancelled before he joined this play's cast. Katie Finneran was also on a short-lived sitcom, The Michael J. Fox Show, and here she plays Budder as such a dim bulb that you wonder how she was ever a successful producer.
Micah Stock plays Gus with a vocal quality that falls somewhere between Sheldon on The Big Bang Theory and Emo Phillips. There's a running gag of Gus bringing in ridiculous coats and identifying their unseen owners, and Stock's delivery often made these lines funnier than they had any right to be. In contrast, Broderick plays the least funny character of the bunch with an oddly nasal tone that wasn't always loud enough. It was disappointing to see a Broadway veteran like him seem less than fully invested in his performance.
Stockard Channing and F. Murray Abraham demonstrated what show business veterans can really be capable of, I was impressed by both. Although I cringed a little at the gags about Virginia Noyes' cocaine habit and ankle bracelet, Channing remained likeable. Pancholy, another sitcom veteran (Weeds, 30 Rock) played the British director very broadly but I think that was the intention since he's a pretty eccentric character.
Overall, It's Only a Play was very funny throughout, and is self-aware about how difficult it is to put on a Broadway show, and the fact that it probably isn't the end of the world if your show gets bad reviews. You can always move on to the next project and retain hope that a naive producer will give you a second chance.
Update: This show has ended it's limited run. Hopefully it will make a return some day.
Stockard Channing and F. Murray Abraham demonstrated what show business veterans can really be capable of, I was impressed by both. Although I cringed a little at the gags about Virginia Noyes' cocaine habit and ankle bracelet, Channing remained likeable. Pancholy, another sitcom veteran (Weeds, 30 Rock) played the British director very broadly but I think that was the intention since he's a pretty eccentric character.
Overall, It's Only a Play was very funny throughout, and is self-aware about how difficult it is to put on a Broadway show, and the fact that it probably isn't the end of the world if your show gets bad reviews. You can always move on to the next project and retain hope that a naive producer will give you a second chance.
Update: This show has ended it's limited run. Hopefully it will make a return some day.